National Review Op-Ed Absolutely Wallops Trump for $5K Giveaway Scheme: ‘Morally, Practically, and Politically Catastrophic’

(The Yomiuri Shimbun via AP Images )

National Review columnist Charles C. W. Cooke eviscerated President Donald Trump’s $5K scheme to convince Americans to vote Republican in the midterm elections.

Under the headline, “Trump Breaks Glass, Joins Socialists, Embraces Bribery,” Cooke called Trump’s proposal at the GOP’s midterm convention Wednesday night, “just preposterous.”

“Painfully aware that, once the midterms are over, he risks being gradually consigned to irrelevance, President Trump has hit once again upon a Hail Mary plan for political success. That plan is bribery,” Cooke wrote. “Last night, after vocally condemning the rise of socialism in the United States, Trump pledged some of his own. ‘If the Republicans win,’ he told a crowd in Houston, ‘I will issue a dividend to every adult citizen in the United States of America for $5,000.’”

“No, no, no, no, no,” Cooke wrote. “Did I mention ‘no’”?

In an accompanying X post, Cooke called Trump’s proposal “morally, practically, and politically catastrophic” — themes that he laid out in his article.

Cooke discussed the “obvious moral problem” for conservatives: “There is no reason whatsoever that each adult in America should be sent money from the federal government,” calling it “a reckless, shapeless, irritable spasm, divorced from the nature and purpose of our government and from the Constitution that created it.”

Secondly, Cooke called the practicality of the matter, “irresponsible.”

“Sending $5,000 checks to every adult would cost around $1.3 trillion — more than the entire federal discretionary budget for 2026, and equivalent to about ten years of revenues from the tariffs that Trump’s feckless vice president insists will pay for this latest foray,” Cooke wrote.

And thirdly, Cooke wrote that “Politically, the act would confirm for all time that the second Trump administration has been a failure.”

“Trump was returned to office because a majority of voters believed that he could get inflation under control and thereby lower prices,” Cooke wrote. “Instead, Trump has publicly called for aggressive interest-rate cuts and imposed tariffs on all sectors of the economy. Adding another $1.3 trillion in stimulus would without doubt make the status quo worse.”

Even Trump’s MAGA base, which celebrates his bombastic populism, “will not be able to outrun mathematics forever,” Cooke wrote, adding, “A society that permits its government to extort it will be a society without virtue.”

New: The Mediaite One-Sheet "Newsletter of Newsletters"
Your daily summary and analysis of what the many, many media newsletters are saying and reporting. Subscribe now!